Could Allah Have a Son?
Browse all parts & issues
Quran 39:4 says: “If Allah had intended to take a son, He could have chosen from what He creates whatever He willed.” Quran 19:35 says it is “not befitting” for Allah to take a son, but the conditional in 39:4 treats it as possible. Yet Quran 6:101 argues it is impossible for a different reason: “How could He have a son when He has no consort?” The first text says a son would be chosen from creation (no consort needed); the second says a son is ruled out for lack of a consort.
Common Muslim Responses
Commentators read 6:101 as a reductio against the pagan Meccans’ notion of literal divine offspring, and 39:4 as a hypothetical showing Allah’s self-sufficiency; both deny sonship, so there is no contradiction in doctrine.
Counter-Rebuttal
The doctrinal conclusion is consistent, critics agree — but the arguments are mutually undermining, and more importantly, both attack a biological-procreation concept of sonship that no Christian creed ever held. Nicene Christianity explicitly confesses the Son as “begotten, not made… not created,” eternal, without consort or procreation. An omniscient author correcting Christianity would have engaged the doctrine Christians actually profess; the Quran instead refutes a crude caricature (see also 5:116 below).