Stars as Missiles, Seven Earths, and the Solid Sky
Browse all parts & issues
The Quran describes the stars (lamps adorning “the nearest heaven”) as projectiles hurled at eavesdropping devils (Quran 67:5; 37:6–10; 72:8–9), conflating stars with meteors. It teaches seven heavens in layers and “of the earth, the like of them” — seven earths (65:12). The sky is a “ceiling, protected” (21:32) held up without visible pillars (31:10), which could fall on the earth (34:9), and on the Last Day will be rolled up like a scroll (21:104); the earth is spread out like a carpet or bed (2:22; 15:19; 71:19; 88:20). HadithhadithA report of Muhammad's words, actions, or tacit approvals. The hadith corpus is the second source of Islamic law after the Quran.Full glossary → complete the picture: the sun travels daily to prostrate beneath Allah’s Throne before being commanded to rise again (Sahih al-Bukhari 3199, commenting on Quran 36:38).
Common Muslim Responses
Apologists treat the shooting-star passages as describing meteors only (the “lamps” doing double duty), the seven heavens as atmospheric layers or unseen dimensions, the spread-out earth as phenomenological description of the earth’s habitable surface (with 79:30 dahaha sometimes translated “made egg-shaped”), and Bukhari 3199 as the sun’s metaphorical prostration of submission.
Counter-Rebuttal
The critic’s reply: the texts form a coherent ancient cosmology — flat extended earth, solid layered firmament, celestial lamps in the lowest layer, a literal divine throne above — which matches the Near Eastern world-picture of the period point for point, and every modern reading must take each element in isolation and allegorize it against its plain sense and its classical interpretation. The “egg-shaped earth” translation of dahaha is a modern invention unknown to classical tafsirtafsirClassical Quranic exegesis — the commentary tradition (al-Tabari, al-Razi, Ibn Kathir, etc.) that explains and contextualizes the text.Full glossary → (which glossed it “spread out”). Seven atmospheric layers do not exist as discrete heavens, and no reading of 65:12 produces seven earths. As with embryology, the Quran’s cosmos is the cosmos of its time and place.