Crucifixion Before Crucifixion Existed
Browse all parts & issues
The Quran has Pharaoh in Moses’ day threaten to crucify people on palm trunks (Quran 7:124; 20:71; 26:49), and describes crucifixion in Joseph’s Egypt (12:41). Crucifixion as a method of execution is attested from the first millennium BC (Assyrians/Persians, then Carthaginians and Romans); there is no evidence of it in New Kingdom or Middle Kingdom Egypt, roughly half a millennium to a millennium earlier.
Common Muslim Responses
Defenders argue salb in Arabic can denote impalement or exposure of a corpse on a stake or tree, which ancient Egypt did practice (some point to “putting to the stake” in Egyptian sources), so the verses need not mean Roman-style crucifixion.
Counter-Rebuttal
Critics answer that the Quran’s own usage fixes the meaning: the same verb describes the punishment in 5:33 alongside amputation, and 4:157 uses it for the crucifixion of Jesus — Roman crucifixion. The Pharaoh verses also specify crucifixion “on the trunks of palm trees” with mass application to the magicians, which reads as the standard punishment-scene of late antiquity retrojected into the Bronze Age, alongside the anachronistic dirham coins paid for Joseph (12:20, silver coinage appearing only c. 600 BC).